Phase: | After/Explain/Elaborate |
Activity: | 1. Teacher will provide the Survey of Parents Regarding Cell Phone Policies in US Middle Schools, 2017 to students. 2. Teacher will inform students that they will analyze the article in order to identify a claim. 3. Teacher will read the headline of the article to students, and tell them that they have around 8 minutes to read the article with a group in order to determine a claim being argued. 4. Students will work for 8 minutes. Teacher will circulate and assist as necessary. 9. Teacher will reconvene the class and give the following instructions: "Now that you have read the article, take a moment to draft the claim that the author is making. Your group can have more than one, but you should have at least one claim found." 10. Students will work while the teacher circulates for a few minutes. 11. The teacher will reconvene the class after roughly 3 minutes. "What have you found to be the claim? Let's hear from each group." 12. Students will share their responses. 13. Teacher will ask students to then write out two pieces of evidence that support the claim they found. 14. Students will submit final answers as a group. |
Assessment Strategies: | Teachers will assess student mastery by reading what students find to be the claim in an argument and the evidence they find to support it. |
Advanced Preparation: | This activity should last approximately 15 minutes. Teacher Materials:
Student Materials:
Teacher Preparation:
Student Preparation:
|
Variation Tips (optional): | Acceleration: Students who need to be challenged can be asked to write a response to the claim within the article. They could also be asked to identify more evidence. Intervention: Students who need intervention could be directed to a set of paragraphs from the entire article to look for their claim to identify. |
Notes or Recommendations (optional): | This activity is preceded by "Defining Claim and Evidence" and "Claiming our School: Analyzing Infographics About Four-Day School Weeks." |
Keywords and Search Tags: | argue, Claim, English, Evidence, identify |