ALEX Learning Activity

  

Compare and Contrast Essay: Writing Prompt & Rubric

A Learning Activity is a strategy a teacher chooses to actively engage students in learning a concept or skill using a digital tool/resource.

You may save this Learning Activity to your hard drive as an .html file by selecting “File”,then “Save As” from your browser’s pull down menu. The file name extension must be .html.
  This learning activity provided by:  
Author: Jessica Byrd
System:Butler County
School:Butler County Board Of Education
  General Activity Information  
Activity ID: 2832
Title:
Compare and Contrast Essay: Writing Prompt & Rubric
Digital Tool/Resource:
Compare and Contrast Essay: Writing Prompt & Rubric
Web Address – URL:
Overview:

This resource includes a writing prompt and a rubric. The activity focuses on expository writing with a compare and contrast structure. The document includes space for students to compose their essays inside the resource. A rubric is provided to students for self-assessment.

This activity was created as a result of the ALEX Resource Development Summit.

  Associated Standards and Objectives  
Content Standard(s):
English Language Arts
ELA2021 (2021)
Grade: 8
8. Produce clear, coherent narrative, argument, and informative/explanatory writing in which the development, organization, style, and tone are relevant to task, purpose, and audience, using an appropriate command of language.

a. Write narratives that establish a clear purpose, use narrative techniques, and sequence events coherently.

Examples: narratives - memoir, short story, personal narrative; techniques - dialogue, pacing, description, reflection;
sequencing - chronological, reverse chronological, flashback

b. Write informative or explanatory texts to examine and convey complex ideas or processes effectively, by developing the topic with relevant information or data from credible sources and using appropriate transitions and precise vocabulary.

c. Write an argument to defend a position by introducing and supporting a claim, distinguishing the claim from opposing claims, presenting counterclaims and reasons, and citing accurate, relevant textual evidence from credible sources.
Unpacked Content
Teacher Vocabulary:
8.
  • Narrative writing
  • Argument writing
  • Informative/explanatory writing
  • Writing development
  • Writing organization
  • Style
  • Tone
  • Task
  • Purpose
  • Audience
  • Command of language
8a.
  • Narratives
  • Clear purpose
  • Narrative techniques
  • Sequence
8b.
  • Informative text
  • Explanatory text
  • Credible sources
  • Transitions
  • Precise vocabulary
8c.
  • Argument
  • Defend a position
  • Claim
  • Opposing claim
  • Counterclaims
  • Relevant evidence
  • Accurate sources
  • Credible sources
Knowledge:
8. Students know:
  • A narrative is a piece of writing that tells a story.
  • The purpose of argumentative writing is to convince the reader to take action or adopt a particular position.
  • Informative or explanatory text is a piece of writing that provides factual information that was gathered from multiple research sources.
  • The development, organization, style, and tone of writing will change depending on the writing task, the purpose of the writing, and the intended audience.
  • Formal academic writing should demonstrate an appropriate command of language.
8a.
  • A narrative is a piece of writing that tells a story, such as a memoir, a short story, or a personal narrative.
  • Narrative writing includes techniques, like dialogue, pacing, description, and reflection.
  • Events in narrative writing should be sequenced in a coherent manner, such as chronological, reverse chronological, or the inclusion of flashbacks.
8b.
  • Informative or explanatory text is writing that examines and explains complex ideas or processes, utilizing information from multiple credible research sources.
  • Informative or explanatory text has an organized structure, and usually begins by clearly focusing on the topic, providing credible evidence, and ends with a conclusion.
  • Informative or explanatory writing should include academic, content-specific technical word meanings.
  • Words that indicate transitions.
8c.
  • The purpose of argumentative writing is to defend an opinion.
  • Argumentative writing includes introducing the topic by stating an argumentative claim, relevant evidence to support the claim, distinguishing the claim from opposing claims, acknowledging counterclaims, and a concluding statement.
  • Evidence to support the argument must be collected from various accurate and credible sources.
Skills:
8. Students are able to:
  • Produce clear, coherent narrative, argument, and informative/explanatory writings.
  • Identify the writing task, the purpose of writing, and the intended audience in order to appropriately adapt the development, organization, style, and tone of the writing.
  • Demonstrate command of the written language.
8a.
  • Write a narrative with a coherent sequence of plot events and a clear purpose.
  • Incorporate narrative techniques in their narrative writing, including dialogue, pacing, description, and reflection.
8b.
  • Gather credible information and data from multiple sources.
  • Write an informative or explanatory text with an organized structure and formal style that develops the topic and utilizes appropriate transitions, credible information or data, and technical vocabulary words.
8c.
  • Write an argument to defend a position.
  • Gather evidence from accurate and credible sources to support the claim.
  • Include a claim and relevant evidence in argumentative writing.
  • Acknowledge alternate or opposing claims in argumentative writing.
  • Present counterclaims and supporting reasons in argumentative writing.
Understanding:
8. Students understand that:
  • There are different genres of writing that serve various purposes.
  • The writing task, purpose, and audience should be considered in the development, organization, style, and tone of the writing.
  • Formal academic writing should display their command of the English language.
8a.
  • Narrative writing can take many forms, but there should be a coherent sequence of events.
  • Literary techniques are tools that can be used to create a piece of narrative writing.
  • Literary techniques in narrative writing contribute to the overall meaning and purpose of the text.
8b.
  • Informative or explanatory writing follows a predictable, organized text structure that utilizes appropriate transition words and precise vocabulary.
  • They must gather their information and data about the topic from multiple credible research sources.
  • Using credible information/data can support a writer's ideas and claims.
  • Writers elaborate on details included in the text by using formal academic, content-specific technical words.
8c.
  • To effectively defend a position, they must present relevant, well-organized evidence from accurate and credible sources.
  • An argument can be more effective if a writer acknowledges opposing viewpoints and counterclaims.
Learning Objectives:

Students will be able to compose an objective expository essay that compares and contrasts two similar subjects with a logical organizational structure.

Students will be able to use transitions to communicate a message clearly and effectively.

Students will be able to correctly follow language conventions to clearly communicate a message. 

Students will be able to provide relevant, credible information to support and develop their message.

  Strategies, Preparations and Variations  
Phase:
After/Explain/Elaborate
Activity:

1. The teacher will share the Compare and Contrast Essay resource with students by either adding it to their digital classroom or sharing it directly through email.

2. Students will be prompted to make a copy of the resource.

3. The teacher will explain the writing prompt to the students.

4. The teacher should review the rubric with the students before they begin writing.

5. The students should be given time to plan, draft, and revise their work.

6. The teacher will grade student work using the attached rubric and return it to students. It is suggested that teachers provide additional feedback in the document where appropriate.

Assessment Strategies:

A rubric is included within the resource. This rubric will assess the following learning objectives:

Students will be able to compose an objective expository essay that compares and contrasts two similar subjects with a logical organizational structure.

Students will be able to use transitions to communicate a message clearly and effectively.

Students will be able to correctly follow language conventions to clearly communicate a message. 

Students will be able to provide relevant, credible information to support and develop their message.


Advanced Preparation:

Students should have been exposed to instruction on the main components of an expository essay and the writing process before completing this activity. The teacher will need to share the resource with students either by adding it to their digital classroom or by sharing it with students directly via email. 

Variation Tips (optional):

The resource can be adapted for use with a variety of expository writing prompts. The resource may also be used as a pre-assessment before teaching an expository writing unit. 

Notes or Recommendations (optional):

This resource can be printed for pencil and paper use. 

Although this resource focuses specifically on expository writing, [ELA2021](8) 8b, it could easily be adapted to work with persuasive writing, [ELA2021](8) 8c.

Corresponding activities are available here--

Expository Writing: Expand Vocabulary

Compare and Contrast Essay: Writing Lab

  Keywords and Search Tags  
Keywords and Search Tags: compare, contrast, ELA202188b, essay, expository, informational, organization, prompt, rubric, transitions, write, writing